RSS Feed

Raptor: 2 player brilliance in the Jurassic era

Raptor: 2 player brilliance in the Jurassic era

pic2520016_md

Raptor

  • Designer: Bruno Cathala and Bruno Faidutti
  • Artist: Vincent Dutrait
  • Publisher: Matagot
  • Player count: 2
  • Play time: 25 minutes
  • Mechanics: Action point allowance, hand management, simultaneous action selection.

Mamma Raptor has escaped from her run and laid her eggs in the park. A team of scientists must neutralize her and capture the baby raptors before they run wild into the forest.

Overview:

Raptor is a 2-player, asymetrical card game from the design duo of Bruno Cathala and Bruno Faiduti. 1 player plays a group of scientists who want to capture and study the baby raptors. The other player plays the raptor family consisting of 5 babies and one very cranky mama raptor.

The board is set up using square tiles in a 3 x 2 grid. Also, there are 4 L-shaped exit tiles which go on each end of the board. On each of the double sided central tiles, you place rocks as depicted on the art. These block movement and line of sight for both scientists and the raptors. The raptor player places the mother on one of the 2 middle tiles and one baby on each of the other tiles. The scientist player initially places 4 out of his 10 scientists, each on one of the exit tiles.

pic2722556_md

Nowhere to run!

Both players have a deck of 9 cards and will have a hand of 3 available to them during each round. These cards have a number from 1 to 9 on them and an associated action. For instance, the scientists player can set fire to the jungle,call in reinforcements or put baby raptors to sleep. The Raptor player has completely different card abilities. The mother can possibly disappear from the board to ‘scout’ placing her back on any spot after the scientists used their action. He can then wait with selecting a card until after the scientist reveals theirs.

pic2520335_md

sample cards

pic2520337_md

Sample cards 2

A round resolves as follows: After both players have selected and revealed a card, the card with the lowest value gets to perfrom the action of the card. The other player gets action points equal to the difference between the two cards. If players would reveal cards with identical value, both would be discarded without effect. The action points can be spent on several things, again varying per player. The Raptor player can use these actions to move the raptor babies one space, move the mother in a straight line, eat adjacent scientists, wake up sleeping babies or put out fires. The Scientists can use their points to put to sleep babies or put a sleep token on the mother raptor (restricting her movements in the future), catch a sleeping baby raptor, move scientists one space or calm down scared scientists. One thing to note is that each scientist figure can only do one agressive action each turn, so it’s impossible to put to sleep a baby and capture it with one scientist in a single turn.

Play continues untill one of the victory conditions are met. For the Raptors this means either having 3 baby’s escape off the board or ending a turn without scientists on the board. For the scientist it’s either capturing 3 baby’s or subdueing the mother (putting 5 sleep counters on her).

 

The review:

When I play boardgames, more often then not it will be in a group consisting of at least three players. That being said, I have a really big soft spot for 2 player games. Especially ones with an Asymetrical nature. I’ve read about this game just before Essen 2015 and I was immediately intrigued by the idea. Especially when I heard that my favorite duo of Bruno’s were going to be the designers. It’s taken me quite a while to track down a copy of the game, but I’m really happy I eventually did. Man this game is so good. It ticks all the boxes of what I like to see in 2 player games.

pic2746914_md

Box contents

What I like about the game:

  1.  Component quality: The game is beautifully illustrated. From the cards to the tiles. A couple of things stand out: The tiles are double sided, with different art on them. Absolutely unnecessary, but a lovely little detail. The second thing that stood out to me is the 10 unique figures for the scientists. Really nice!
  2. Well presented theme: The art is really evocative and the miniatures help in this regard as well. I can really see myself in Jurassic world while playing.
  3. easy to setup and teach: The rules for this game are very easy to teach and you can get a game going in less then 5 minutes.
  4. Play time: The game easily plays in under half an hour. It’s really easy to play multiple times after each other.
  5. Clever mechanics: I really like the cardplay in this game. Especially the action points you get for the difference between two card. This makes for some very interesting decisions.
  6. Great player aids and rule book: These are just outstanding. They even had Dutch rules which were actually not just thrown through google translate. As this is a bit of a pet-pieve of mine I really think it deserves a special mention.
  7. Dinosaurs: Nuff said!

What I didn’t like as much:

  1. Balance?: It might be a little bit early to say after 5 plays, but to me it seems a bit easier to win as the scientists. I’m pretty sure the game is actually very well balanced and it will equal out after more plays. I do think that the scientists are a tad easier to play at first, though.
pic2695084_md

Clever Girl!

Final Verdict: 8,5/10

 

10 x 10 challenge: Month 1 recap and new challenge added

10 x 10 challenge: Month 1 recap and new challenge added

January has come and gone faster then I would have wanted. Gamingwise it was a reasonably good month for me with 48 games played and 12 games I’ve played for the first time. These are pretty good numbers for me, as I usually strive to play a game a day one avarage.

It was also the first month of my 10 x 10 challenge. Let’s take a little look at the graph:

10 x 10 january

Status at the end of January

To be completely honest, I don’t think I’ve done too well in the first month. I’m very happy with my multiple plays of broom service and codenames (even though that one feels a bit like a copout and might still change). It’s a shame I didn’t get to play Mombasa this month as well as Battlelore and Arcadia quest. Even though February is a relatively short month, I have some gaming plans that should help me stay on target.

When selecting the list of games for the 10 x 10 challenge, I intentionally left some heavier, longer games off the list. During the month I started thinking I could really use an incentive to play some heavier games more frequently as well, so that’s why I’ve decided to up the ante a bit and constructed a second list:

collage-2016-02-04

This second challenge started on 1-2-2016, which means I will only have 11 months to play these 5 titles 5 times each. I’ve chosen the following games:

 

  1. The Dilluvia project: One of the spielworkxx releases from 2015. I’ve not had time to play this one yet, because I’ve been struggling with the rules. A playthrough video has helped solve this though, so I should be good to go.
  2. Scythe: It’s not even out yet and will only be released around august/september. I still think I’ll manage 5 plays pretty easily
  3. The Gallerist: My favorite designer did not have a space on the other list, so I’m doubling up here. The gallerist was my favorite game of 2015, so I hope I’ll be able to play some more this year.
  4. CO2: And the other Vital Lacerda title on the list. I really like the way this game feels and I think it will be well liked by most of my gaming group.
  5. Trickerion: This game is a huge table hog. I probably will only play with 4 people during the monthly game day due to space constraints. I love the theme and look of this game though, so I have high hopes.

On the 10 x 10 page, you’ll also be able to follow this challenge with a continuosly updated graph:

5x5 challenge start

Empty so far.

Take care guys and see you around.

 

Sjtollie

Elysium: Build your own Olympian legend

Elysium: Build your own Olympian legend

Elysium

  • Designer: Matthew Dunstand, Brett J Gilbert
  • Artist: Various
  • Publisher: Space Cowboys
  • Player count: 2-4
  • Play time: 60 minutes
  • Mechanics: Set collection, drafting, Tableau building

A1ZRfxKyE4L._SL1500_

Mythic Greece. As an upstart demigod, you want to earn the favor of the Olympians and become a figure of legend yourself. Gather heroes and powerful artifacts, please the gods and bear their power to write your own epic tale.

Let your allies achieve their destiny and enter the Elysium, home of the glorious and the brave. Once the stories are written, only one demigod will be chosen to stand at the side of Zeus.

Overview:

Elysium is basically a card drafting game where players recruit cards and quests from a common pool each round, using a very innovative mechanism (more on that later).

The game is played over 5 rounds. During set-up of the games, 5 of the available 8 families are chosen and shuffled together to form the playdeck. The 8 families each have a deck of 21 cards, with every deck being very different from the others. The following families are available in the game:

pic2356837_md

a sample of some Hades cards.

  • Zeus (lots of extra scoring possibilities)
  • Ares (introduces prestige points. Another way to score points)
  • Hades (Focuses on transferring cards to the elysium)
  • Poseidon (messes with other players)
  • Apollo (adds the oracle to the game. An additional set of 4 cards)
  • Hermes (uses powers from other player’s cards)
  • Athena (powerfull abilities, but gives opponent something as well)
  • Hephaestus (Focus lies on gold)
pic2349947_lg

A sample of some Zeus cards

Once a card is recruited, it is immediately placed in a player’s domain. This is the area above his personal player board. Quest tiles, once selected, are placed next to your player board and determine a couple of things:

pic2365512_md.png

Quests

  1. player order (activates in the next phase)
  2. the amount of gold and possibly victory points a player gains
  3. the amount of cards a player is allowed to transfer to his Elysium (the area below his player board)

Each player has a set of 4 different colored columns. These are what determines which cards you can acquire during your turn. Each card has a combination of colors in the top right corner. You need to have the columns in those colors available to be able to take a card. After your selection you need to discard one of your columns. (not necessarily one of the ones you used this turn to bu a card.) This means that as the round progresses, you’ll have less choice. The same goes for quests, apart from the fact that you need to discard the exact color of the quest you took. pic2683021_md.jpg

In some circumstance you might not have the resources to aquire a card during your final actions. In that case, you take a citizen card. (represented by the back of all cards). These count as wild cards f

pic2353402_md

A citizen card

or set collection purposes, but penalise you during end scoring. If you don’t have a column left to get a quest, you flip one of the remaining ones and flip it. These broken/failed quests give considerably less rewards.

There are several types of abilities on each card. Some are activated instantaneous once you recruit them. Others are activated once, once per turn or at game end for instance. Below you can seen a nice picture with all different abilities.

Cards only have abilities once they are in a player’s domain. At some point however, players will try to transfer cards to their Elysium and build legends with them, as that’s what scores points at the end of the game. transfering a card to the elysium costs money, depending on the level of the card.  Legends can be built in 2 different ways. either by family or by level. A complete family legend consists of a level 1,2 and 3 card of the same family. For each family in the game there are 2 bonus tokens, rewarding players that complete a family legend first. The legends by level consists of up to 5 cards of different families, but of the same level. There are bonus tokens for these available as well, but these are held onto by the player currently in posession of the largest legend of that level.

pic2682952_md

Level bonus tokens

During end scoring a couple of things are scored. Whoever has the most points after this scoring wins the game:

  • per legend points are scored based on the amout of cards in it.
  • bonus tokens
  • points gained during play
  • Chronos powers on cards in your elysium
  • Prestige points (If Ares is used)
  • deduct points for citizens in your elysium

 

The Review

For those of you that have read the entry of my top 10 games for 2015, it might not come as a surprise that I really enjoy this game. The overal presentation is very well done. Each family deck is illustrated by a different artist. Even though ther art styles are very different, it somehow still feels very cohesive. The box insert is very clever. The quality of the components is fine for the price point. I’ve sleeved my copy as I think the cards will suffer from multiple plays. Even though most mechanics used in the game are very familiar, I think the restrictions in selecting your cards was really well done. The game can be easily expanded upon as some of the greek gods were missing from this game                  (I personally would love to see decks for Aphrodite, Hera, Dyonisus and Artemis) Maybe stand alone expansions with other pantheons would be an option as well, but I don’t really see that happening.

In another review I’ve seen a variant where the Oracle, which normally only gets used if Apollo is present in the game, is allways used. I have yet to try this variant, but I think the bit of foreshadowing for the next round could be a welcome addition for some players.

pic2413897_md.png

The oracle

What I like about the game:

  1. Replayability: With only 5 families in each game, there is tons of replayability. Each set-up has a very distinct feel
  2. Overal Presentation: I mentioned most of this already, but I love how this game looks
  3. Rulebook: Well layed out and very easy to understand
  4. Plays well with all player counts.
  5. Clear iconography: No need to check the book very often.
  6. play time: By no means a filler, but the 60 minutes on the box is very accurate. Ideal for it’s ‘weight’.

What I didn’t like as much:

  1. Very thin theme: Even though I like the theme, it’s really only pasted on very thinly. I somehow don’t get the feeling I’m a demigod trying to find my place in Olympus.
  2. Take that: It can be very nasty at times.
  3. Ares: I get the feeling that you can simply not neglect prestige points when they are present in the game. The difference between 1st and 3rd place (16 to 4) is very big in my opinion. In my plays with Ares (5 at this point) were never won by the player who scored 3rd or 4th place in Presitge points.

 

Final verdict: 8/10

 

Top 10: Most anticipated games for 2016

Top 10: Most anticipated games for 2016

iStock_000012645257XSmall_6d9

 

Lists! We gamers really seem to love them. We list our favourite games, our gaming goals for the next year, our collections and plays…… If we could, we could make a list for nearly anything. One thing that I always try to do is keep up with upcoming releases. I read forums, news snippets on BGG, you name it. With the compiled info I can normally easily make a decision if I’ll be interested in a game or not.

Mostly this comes down to some very simple criteria:

  • Do I know and like the designer?
  • Who is publishing the game?
  • Is the theme something that interests me?
  • What type of game is it, what are the core mechanics? (if possible I check if there are already some rules online
  • Is it something that would fit my group, kids or boardgameclub?
  • How is it presented?
  • What is the expected price going to be? (who am I kidding, really 😛 )

Based mostly on these criteria, I’ve compiled a list with the 10 releases, I’m looking forward to the most in 2016. We’ll start with number 10 and work our way down the list to my most anticipated game.

 

10: Tiny epic Western

tewTiny epic western is the newest game by Gamelyn games. They are mostly known for their “Tiny epic” series of games, of which I have played a few. Even though I haven’t liked everything that they’ve brought out. (I really didn’t care for Tiny epic Defenders for instance) This game combines worker placement with a simplified poker resolution mechanic, which really sounds interesting to me. Apart from that every player has a character with a unique power and  the presentation of it all is really neat.They are currently running a kickstarter for this game, so if you like what you’re reading head over to the page now using this link.

9: Histrio

pic2697488_mdTo be quite honest, there is not that much information out yet about this release, but it’s still high on my radar based on some of the criteria I mentioned above. Firstly, one of the designers is Bruno Cathala, who has designed many games I really enjoy (five tribes, Abyss, 7 wonders duel). The game is being published by Bombyx, so it will look amazing for sure! Apart frompic2745000_md that, there is a one-liner of information about the game on BGG:Histrio involves animal actors in renaissance times, with players performing dirty tricks and carrying out shenanigans in order to present the best troop possible to fit the mood of the King.   Somehow, that line has really peaked my interest.

8: small box Iello games

Ok, I know that this entry is basically cheating, as I’m talking about more then one game here, but as this is my own little space of interweb I think I should be able to get away with it. Iello has grown from a large french publisher, to become one of the world’s leading companies over the years. Games like King of Tokyo and King of new york are taking the world by storm and apart from their own releases, they do french releases of many well known and well loved titles.

I, However, like them best for their smaller box games. Biblios, Nyet and Welcome to the dungeon have all become some of my favorite fillers and see many plays at our game club events. Then there is the tales and games series, a special line of terrific kids games that they do. Both of these lines will be getting some new releases this year, of which I’m most looking forward to Kenjin, Candy Chaser and Tales and games: The pied piper.

7: A feast for odin

pic116113_tAgain, there is not too much known about this title yet. All I really know is that it’s the newest Uwe Rosenburg game and it will be published by Feuerland spiele. It promises to be a heavy euro as we’re accustomed to from Uwe’s previous designs (Ora et Labora, Fields of arle, Le havre, Agricola etc..) and as long as it doesn’t have a penalty system like Agricola, I’ll be on board. The title suggests that the theme will have something to do with norse mythology, which is allways a plus for me.

6: Splotter spellen reprints

 

Here I go again with the cheating, I promise it will be the last time for this list. I’ve always had an admiration for the dutch design duo of Jeroen Doumen and Joris Wiersinga. Partially, because they are my countrymen and I feel a bit of national pride doesn’t hurt. Also, I’ve allways wanted to play some of their games but have never had the chance. As most of their games are out of print, they are hard to come by and extremely expensive on the secondary markets. When I heard about the upcoming reprints, I was super excited as maybe I’ll finally get a chance to play classics like Indonesia and The great Zimbabwe

5: Pandemic Legacy, Season 2

k2-_47a7d64e-be41-4ba2-ba97-59eb9d6ab6ed.v1One of the best boardgaming experiences I have ever had was playing the first Season of Pandemic Legacy, so naturally I want to play the second season. There’s nothing really known yet about that game, apart from that it will come out this year. I do sincerely hope that we go in an entirely different direction this season, but somehow I don’t have to worry.

 

4: Arcadia quest: Inferno

I’ve had so much fun with the base ga650x650_2d72d65844c6b08ebbb09e0f12c63659c9b667e77931f3aea6997200me so far and have many things left to explore there. That doesn’t mean I’m not terribly excited to get my grubby little paws on the ‘expansion’ that was recently kickstarted. There is an awefull lot of stuff that will come with this game:aq An entirely new campaign, a pets expansion (also with a new campaign), Dragons! Demons! Angels! I hope to have my current AQ stuff painted before this will show up….

 3: Lisboa

pic2345949_mdI’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: I love Vital Lacerda!!! (I’m talking about his games of course). During Spiel in Essen last year, I had a chance to talk to the man behind some of my favorite games and there he told me about his newest design that would be released in 2016, Lisboa. I’ve been following any news I can find about this game and so far it looks to be amazing. The game is about the reconstruction of the rebuilding of the Portugese Capitol after the 1755 earthquake. Not the most exciting theme to be honest, but if he’ll manage to incorporate the theme into the game mechanics it should prove to be very interesting. It will be a city building, economic game and probably on the heavier spectrum of euro games. If you would like to read more on Lisboa, I’d highly recommend checking out the BGG page.

2: Vinhos: Deluxe edition

How would you react when your favorite game, from your favorite designer gets a deluxe edition?  Well, my reaction was kinda like this:meme2

I’ve been trying to find a copy for myself for a long time (and still am by the way) but when Vital told me a kickstarer for a deluxe edition produced by Eagle gryphon games would be launched in January I couldn’t contain myself. Apart from a massive component upgrade, the game will be strepic2649446_mdamlined quite a bit. I personally love the new art style of the game, but this is off course a matter of taste. I’d say check the BGG page out and decide for yourself. As soon as the Kickstarter launches, I’ll be sure to write about it on the blog.

One last thing, if you follow Vital on twitter, you’ll find lots of info an pictures about his new releases. Highly recommended! @vitallacerda.

 

 

 

1: Scythe

pic2323719_md.jpgAnd finally, number one on the list could only go to Scythe. The newest game from king of kickstarter, Jamey stegmaier. The Kickstarter for Scythe was run late 2015 and was by far the best kicksater project I have ever followed. Frequent, meaningful updates, backer interaction and awesome commitment from the designer and artist. Wow, just Wow!

Scythe is a 4 (3.5 really) X game set in an alternate history 1920’s europe. The game is pic2789227_md.jpgbased upon a series of artwork from artist Jakub Rozalski. In the game you play as one of the 5 factions of Eastern Europa, farming for food and staking your claim in the lands around a mysterious factory.  Scythe is pretty much a sandbox game, where apart from a hidden objective card you are free to roam the lands and find your own way. Decisions come in the form of encounter cards, which will let you choose your destiny. A special note about the components of the game, these are absolutely stunning. From individual mechs and leader figures, to beautiful metal coins, it all looks top notch. If this game will turn out half as good as I expect it to be, it will be one of the best games in it’s genre ever.

 

 

So, that’s it for this list. Be sure to follow boardgameblues to see all updates. What game are you excited about? Leave a comment with your own choices.

Sjtollie

 

Champions of Midgard: Definitely not a LOW clone

Champions of Midgard: Definitely not a LOW clone

Champions of Midgard

  • Designer: Ole Steiness
  • Artist: Victor Pérez Corbella
  • Publisher: Grey Fox Games
  • Player count: 2-4
  • Playtime: 60-90 minutes
  • Mechanics: Worker placement, dice combat

Champions-of-Midgard-Box-Front_g5a4ac

Champions of Midgard is a middleweight, Viking-themed, worker placement game with dice rolling in which players are leaders of Viking clans who have traveled to an embattled Viking harbor town to help defend it against the threat of trolls, draugr, and other mythological Norse beasts. By defeating these epic creatures, players gain glory and the favor of the gods. When the game ends, the player who has earned the most glory earns the title of Jarl and is recognized as a champion of Midgard!

Placing workers allows for the collection of resources and warriors, which players may then send on journeys to neighboring villages or across the sea to defeat monsters and gain the glory they need for victory. Resources are used to to carve runes, build ships, and feed your followers. Viking warriors (custom dice) do battle with the myriad enemies the town faces.

Overview:

The game is played over 8 rounds, which each follow the exact same structure. A round is divided in the 5 following Phases:

20151108_132453_8e31: Round setup: This phase has several small steps that need to be taken to proceed.

  • Monsters will be drawn from the top of their respective decks and will, in the case of trolls and draugr, replace any current ones. In the case of the journey monsters, only refill the empty spots.
  • Place a face down journey card on each empty journey space
  • Reveal the top card from the merchant ship deck
  • Add the appropriate die to the swordsmith, hafter and blacksmith locations
  • add a food cube to the smokehouse location

 

2: Worker placement:

In this phase, starting with the player holding the first player marker, players place their workers on the locations on the board. Doing this they gather resources: Wood, Food, Favor, money and warriors (dice) in three different varieties. There are also some spaces on the board where other things can be obtained. Rune cards give the player some additonal abilities during the placement or battle phase. Destiny cards can provide end-game scoring opportunities and ships can be either bought or hired to take your warriors on perilous journeys.20151108_133016_5b4(1)

3: Assigning viking warriors:

Any player that placed their workers on a troll, Draugr or longship location will now assign the warriors (and in the case of a journey food cubes) they wish to send into battle. If a monster has a no spears/axes/swords symbol on it, dice of that color can not be sent into battle with the particular monster.

4: Combat resolution:

The basics of combat are very simple. Each enemy has a wounds stat and an attack stat. If you roll enough sword/spear/axe symbols to equal their wound total it is killed. For each wound the enemy inflicts on you, you lose a die. Wounds can be negated by shield results. You can spend favor tokens to reroll any dice. This step can be repeated by spending additional tokens. Combat ends either when the monster has taken lethal damage or if there are no viking warriors left to combat the monster.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

  • If a player placed warriors in the hunting grounds, he rolls his dice and gains the appropriate amount of food.
  • If a player battles a troll, combat is resolved against the troll. If the troll is not killed, all players take a blame token. If the Troll is killed however, the player may discard a blame token and force another player to take one. If nobody decided to battle the troll menacing their village, all players take a blame token as well. These blame tokens detract points at the end scoring, nicely detailed on a graph on the board.
  • In the Draugr spaces, combat is resolved from left to right.
  • For the journey spaces, follow the following steps, starting with the leftmost location:  Reveal and resolve Journey cards, feed your viking warriors (unfed warriors die and return to the reserve. Food is returned to supply even if there’s any left), combat the monster.

5: Clean up:

Some minor things need to be done in this step. Retrieve your workers from the board. Discard any undefeated Draugr and troll cards. Add 1 money to each undefeated monsters on the bottom and progress the round marker. If you’re in round eight, proceed to final scoring.

Final scoring:

Apart from the points scored during the game, you will score the following things during end scoring.

  1. Destiny cards: If you have statisfied the condition of a card, score the larger amount of Glory points depicted. If you’re tied, score the smaller amount.
  2. Sets of enemies (red/Blue/Gold). Score 5 points for each set collected
  3. Rune cards: Score the amount of glory depicted on the card. (both for used and unused cards)
  4. Private longships: If you’ve built one, score the points indicated.
  5. Favor tokens: Each unspent token is worth 2 glory points.
  6. Gold: Score 1 glory point for each 3 gold you have left.
  7. Blame: Lose points according to the track, depending on your amount of blame tokens.

 

Whoever ends up with the most points, wins the game.

 

The Review:

Before we address the elephant in the room, let me talk a little bit about what I think about Champions of Midgard itself. I have to say I succumbed a little bit to the Dice tower hype about this game, as they gave it a seal of excellence. I really couldn’t wait to get my grubby little hands on this title.

What I like about the game:

  1. The artwork and style throughout is absolutely gorgeous. The board especially is really pleasing to look at.
  2. Ease of rules. The rules were extremely simple to learn and teach to others. It’s a very beginner friendly game.
  3. Playtime: The gamebox says it plays in between 60 to 90 minutes. For me, the plays are closer to the 60 minute mark, which seems just right.
  4. Use of dice. Off course, dice add a luck element to the game. In this case however, I don’t mind at all. It makes the completion of ‘quests’ or battles feel very climatic.
  5. Small mechanics. As an example I really like that getting an additional worker, costs less when you’re not the first person to do so.
  6. Variable player powers. There are 5 different clan leaders that each have a unique ability. Allthough these are not mind blowingly different, they add just a little touch of variety I like.
  7. The designers are very reactive to questions on the BGG boards. A lot of people initially had some questions, but the team behind the game seems really committed to adress these.20151108_132350_0b7

What I didn’t like as much:

  1. Replayability. With only a small amount of marker tiles, setup will often look similar. Also, the monsters could have been more diverse for my tastes.
  2. The rulebook. I know this sounds a bit double, as I put ease of rules as a plus. For me the thing I didn’t like about the rulebook came down to the layout and they way it was written. The rules themselves are pretty straight forward and easy.
  3. Very limited player interaction. Really, apart from taking a spot someone else wants, there is no interaction. I strongly feel that the game would benefit from an expansion that would tackle this issue.

The comparison to Lords of waterdeep (Because all the cool kids are doing it)

Off course, there are some similarities between both games. In both games you collect resourses and complete quests. Also, both games use a resource that detracts points at game end (technically, the expansion to LOW adds this, not the base game)

Is that a crime? Not as far as I’m concerned. The game also have a lot of mechanics that feel very different. Lords of waterdeep is much more interactive. Resources switch hands and you can screw around with your fellow players. It doesn’t have the thrill of combat that Champions of Midgard has. Also something I really feel where the games take a different route is the way the end scoring works. In LOW, you know up front which type of quests will give you game end bonuses. In COM, the addition of set collection and the destiny cards make for a very different approach. In my eyes one game is not necessarily alot better then the other. I don’t see why you couldn’t have both in your collection.

In the end I liked this game well enough, but I would love to see some interaction and replayability added with a future expansion.

Final Verdict: 7,5/10

 

 

 

 

Gameday report: SML january meet-up

Gameday report: SML january meet-up

pic logo

Hey there guys,

on saturday 1-9-2016, SML had it’s monthly meet-up in Roermond, The Netherlands. I happened to take some pictures of the games that were being played, so I thought it might be a good idea to write a little bit about the day for Boardgameblues.

For the organisors, the day started with a few hickups. Due to unforseen sircumstances, we missed one of our ‘staff’ and one of us (myself) had to come a bit later than usual. We also had an alternative venue this month, due to the Carnaval season being in full swing. With these issues take care of, we were off to a slow start, but were happy to meet some new faces. When I got the message only 8 people were in attendance from start, I had to admit I started to feel a bit nervous. When I arrived a couple of hours later though, the room had started to fill up a bit. While wandering around I saw people playing a game of Zombicide with a ton of expansions thrown in. On another table, some people were setting up a game of Carcassone one of the attendees had brought along. She had a very nice, home made wooden chest with an awesome insert to store her many expansions. A true beauty to behold !gameday 2

(I hope I’ll be able to snap a couple of pics of her setup at the february game day as I failed on this part. You do see a bit of it in the back of this picture.

This time we were joined by an entire family as well, it was nice to see the kids games being played for a change. I managed to snap a picture of a game of boom boom balloon in progress, but during the event many others were played as well. gameday 3  One thing we are noticing (and are very glad about) is that for a couple of months the interest in star wars themed games has skyrocketed. Multiple people had their x-wing stuff along and 2 guys played nothing but Imperial assault the entire day.

gameday 4

During dinner time, we lost some of the players, but also gained some others, so we managed to have a constant flow of games being played. A nice thing to note was that even though the family of 4 left around dinner, the dad decided to come back to do some gaming himself afterwards. Awesome!

20160109_195747_42f

The evening brought along some lighter fair for most players. We enjoyed a couple of rounds of codenames and a group of us ended the night with a basic game of broom service. 20160109_211012_6ba

All in all it was a succesfull event, though we hope attendance will pick up once again as 2016 moves forward.

That’s it for now. If you’re ever in the are, be sure to drop by. We play every second saturday of the month from 2 to 10 PM.

Sjtollie.

List of games played (at least the ones I’ve witnessed)

  • Zombicide
  • Nexus ops
  • 7 wonders duel
  • carcassone
  • boom boom balloon
  • Tambuzi
  • Geisterwäldchen
  • Three little pigs
  • Diego Drachenzahn
  • codenames
  • imperial assault
  • broom service
  • lords of waterdeep
  • love letter

 

Sjtollie’s 10 x 10 challenge

Sjtollie’s 10 x 10 challenge

With an ever expanding collection, it’s sometimes hard for me to get some games to the table more than a handfull of times. Over on Boardgamegeek a lot of people are having this same issue apparently, as for several years people are doing a so called “10 x 10 challenge”. This basically means they challenge themselves to play ten different games, ten times each.

I think this is a good initiative, so this year I would like to join in on the fun! I started thinking about games I really wanted to play ten times this year and started making a list. At first, the list contained a lot of really long and heavy games, but somehow this didn’t really felt achievable to me. That’s why I started on adding some diversity to the games for my list. This year, I’ve chosen the following games:

collage-2016-01-07(1)

  1. Isle of skye: A quick game with a lot of replayability and some interesting choices. I don’t own it myself though, so I’ll probably purchase it.
  2. Arcadia Quest: I really want to complete the beyond the grave campaign at least once before Inferno arrives. I also plan on painting my set, but that’s a different story all together…..
  3. Codenames: A secret santa gift from this year. I’ve heard great things so I think this one will be an easy one to achieve. (might up the number along the way).
  4. Viticulture: I love this game so much! One of the most elegant designs out there. I’m sure I’ll find people to help me with completing this one, as it’s pretty popular at our games club.
  5. Broom service: This one is a bit more approachable. I hope to play this game with non-gamers. Somehow I always have a good time while playing this pretty light (but mean) game.
  6. Stronghold (2e): I did a lot of demo’s for this game at Essen last year. I love to explore it a bit more and get some plays in with some of my go-to 2 player buddies.
  7. Russian railroads: I hope this doesn’t make me sound like a snob, but we use this often as a warm-up on heavy euro nights. A lot of replayability, especially with the german railroads expansion.
  8. Mombasa: One of the surprises from last year. Not sure about the replayability though, but I have good faith.
  9. The voyages of Marco polo: Nice middle weight, but quick to play euro game. The random set-up and the different player powers make this game (almost) infinitely replayable. Especially if you add the mini expansion.
  10. Battlelore (2e): My favorite command and colors game. A lot of people in my gaming group own this and I really want to play it more. We’re scheduling a tournament soon, so I hope to get a lot of plays in then.

 

I plan on evaluating my progress after every month, so expect an update on this post next month. I keep track of this challenge in a simple graph, just so I have something visual next to the plays I log on BGG.10 x 10

 

Tell me what you think about my list, will I make it? Maybe you want to join in and comment with your own lists.

See you around next time,

Sjtollie

The Players' Aid

Board Game Reviews, Reports, and Reflections.

Board Game King

Board Game Blog

Board Musings

Melanie's musings on Board and Card Games

What Did You Play This Week Podcast Thing

A Life of Gaming, One Week at a Time

The Nerd Nebula

The Nucleus of the Universe for all Nerd Hacks!

The Opinionated Gamers

Reviews and Commentary on Boardgames